Posted in

Five paranormal investigation shows to aid your hunt for Halloween entertainment

As the nights draw in and temperatures drop, our appetite for horror reaches fever pitch in October – building up to that most glorious of celebrations: Halloween. But as is the case with any festivities, there can be too much of a good thing.

After the umpteenth slasher of your month-long horror marathon, as a house-party slowly peters out in the early hours, or as conversation slows at your All Hallows gathering, the suggestion of another ghoulish feature film may well be met with the same enthusiasm as a turkey sandwich after Christmas dinner.

We all need the occasional palate cleanser – something that’s still on-theme, but which you don’t need to pay attention to, or take remotely seriously. Playing that role perfectly this time of year, is the endless churn of shows where real people take camera crews in search of the paranormal. Everyone wants to make their own Most Haunted. Some have fallen comedically short. Others have long surpassed. They all make for a great refresher, between gorging yourself on Halloween’s main courses.

Here are five top picks for your consideration.

Animal X: Natural Mystery Unit

Animal X is an American and Australian documentary television series that aired in more than 120 countries. It began in 1997 with its first series of 13 half-hour episodes – covering everything from the yeti to Black Shuck. But when Most Haunted exploded into the public conscious, the producers decided to try and capture the zeitgeist, with their own investigation show.

The resulting Natural Mystery Unit is arguably the gold standard of cryptozoology TV. Turning the Camp dial to 11, IFL hall of famer and Razorback star Bill Kerr sits inside a green screen studio pretending to be the ‘mission control’, occasionally phoning his investigation unit to direct them on their actions. And that could honestly be enough to enjoy this – especially when, in spite of all the evidence, Bill still tries to hammily keep our hopes up that maybe there is still a chupacabra somewhere, but they just missed it…

But what really adds another level, is the steadfastly rational zoologists Nathalie and Daniel. Booked to front the in-field segments, they presumably wanted to be able to return to normal work afterwards, so refused to pretend they saw things they didn’t. This commitment to truth-telling leaves to some genuinely funny moments where the camera catches them getting carried away with themselves. Most memorably, while hunting for sasquatch, poor Daniel declares a heat camera has spotted something after dark which must be twice his height, only to stand where the creature had been the next day, and realise it was actually the size of a duck. Certified great hangover viewing for November 1st.

Man vs Monster

In his review of Man v. Monster, Brad Newsome of The Age wrote, “These monster-hunting shows just keep getting dumber and more disingenuous.” Picking the show apart, Newsome claimed that it was “essentially impossible” for presenter Richard Terry to try to find a spider of sufficient size to pluck children out of their beds. My response to this would be “Yes, and?”

Richard Terry is one of the most pointedly absurd monster hunters I have ever seen. A man who in one episode, proudly boasts of his own ingenuity, “Never thought I would be using a machete as a walking stick!” seconds before nearly slicing his finger off, having inevitably slipped. He’s a relatably soft-bodied, middle-aged nature photographer, who Nat Geo relentlessly try to cast as a hulking He-Man – and who can’t help but undermine that billing at every turn. Walking across a log to traverse a river, he falls directly onto his crotch, and is forced to shuffle across the rest of the way, like a dog with worms. And when he doesn’t screw up, he calls attention to all the other artifice in the show. Insisting there is “no other way” to get somewhere but to rappel down a waterfall, he very nearly tumbles into the torrent on various occasions, while a cameraman films him in full-HD from below.

All this in the service of finding creatures which he knows don’t exist, and which the editor has to mute witness testimony for when they identify the correct animal that is the real culprit. And when he finds that animal, his acting skills leave a lot to be desired too; as he does his best to try and pretend that as a nature photographer, he doesn’t know what a fruit bat is. This is a breathless fever dream of a show, now largely available for free on Nat Geo’s YouTube channel – and thus, perfect group viewing when the night winds down.

Dead Files

Sometimes you just want to make a TV show about local history, but nobody’s commissioning that kind of thing. Least of all in America. So, what do you do? Hitch yourself to the ghost show wagon, of course! Retired homicide detective Steve Dischavi loves nothing more than pottering about in the library, speaking to historians, and travelling across the country to talk about social history. In Dead Files, he almost entirely abandons the investigation each week, and gets distracted by stories of trade unionists fighting against murderous coal mine owners; racism, and community battles against the Klan; and white settlers’ genocidal campaign to eradicate Native Americans from the land.

On occasion, this is genuinely interesting work, because the truth of the matter is that if ghosts really were lingering throughout our modern world, those wronged and mistreated spirits would be here as a result of political and social processes that still exist. Sometimes, then Dead Files comes close to touching on some wonderfully uncomfortable home-truths. This is still a ‘regular’ ghost show too though – so at other times, though, it also shits the bed in glorious fashion. Again, there seems to be some desire to maintain some kind of ‘unedited’ authenticity, so the show’s psychic, Amy Allan, often says things which are completely wrong. In these moments, that is said to be because a ghost chose to lie to her – most famously, a spirit she later claimed was Al Capone gave her a completely different name.

In a bid to distinguish the show from other pretenders, meanwhile Dead Files has a gimmick where a guest artist attempts to draw a composite sketch of the spirits Amy has seen. And let’s just say, some liberty seems to have been taken with the use of the words ‘sketch’ and ‘artist’ in the show’s promo. Highlights include a ‘dog’ that seems to be man wearing a morph suit while striking a provocative pose; and a portrait of the home-owner hosting the investigation which is so insulting that a mortified Steve fails to stifle a “Jesus Fucking Christ” when the image is revealed. The show often got criticise for being “fake” (which, well, I have some upsetting news for you about all the paranormal shows you think are legit…); but honestly, you can’t fake that. Watch with friends, in a place where your shrieks of embarrassment won’t be a problem.

Help! My House is Haunted

Any exposure to Ghost Adventures will instantly present you irrefutable evidence of one thing: Zak Bagans absolutely sucks as a television presenter. He renders everything he appears in unwatchable. But as creator of Help! My House is Haunted, I have to give him props. This guy gets comedic casting in a way you just can’t teach.

Sure, it took a few iterations to get it right, but in its current form, this show – which features a trio of paranormal investigators trying to rid British home-owners of ghosts tanking their resale value – is fronted by people who are each inept in their own way, and who genuinely seem to dislike each other. That friction makes for some fantastically watchable nonsense. The lead psychic, introduced by the bombastic voiceover as “Medium Ian” (I want a spin-off where we also meet Small Ian and Large Ian), has a voice like if Kermit the Frog was from Scunthorpe – seems to have a particular dislike for co-host and tech-expert Barri Ghai.

Barri is notably insecure about proceedings – wearing a tactical stab-proof vest to every outing. It’s not clear why he thinks this would help stop a ghost from attacking him; and instead, it just seems to provoke Medium Ian’s ire – as he routinely calls upon spirits to show they are present by doing something to Barri. In a recent episode of ‘Celebrity’ Help! My House is Haunted, this supposedly led to the ghost of George Best paralysing Barri by tickling him. Meanwhile, in another regular episode, when a home-owner was getting a bit too real, and started looking at Medium Ian like he wanted to personally send him to the other side, the psychic tactfully decided to position Barri between himself and the increasingly violent man. Great TV – and worthy party viewing.

Daisy May and Charlie Cooper’s Nightwatch

If bullying is your thing, you might also try Ghost Bait – a show where the crew place the already terrified home-owner in a dark and deserted room, with a burlap sack over their head, to see how long it takes before they crack – but that’s not for everyone. Sometimes you need a gentler watch, featuring people who might actually enjoy each other’s company. This next pick is perfect for that.

Low on shenanigans, high on banter, Daisy May and Charlie Cooper’s Nightwatch sees the siblings behind comedy hit This Country tour spooky locations across the UK – just in the hope of seeing a ghost. Unfortunately – or fortunately – for them, the scariest things they encounter in the reputably haunted locations tend to be bouts of flatulence, or finding out which notorious historical figures they might be distantly related to.

It’s not something which you will find much meat in if you are looking for supernatural entertainment – the Coopers don’t find the time for any of the bells and whistles of modern ghost hunting, simply turning up and seeing whatever they see. No special radios, no infrared cameras, no psychic third team member. But in the peace of the room, once the decision has been made on who gets top bunk, there is a wonderful warmth between them, bantering into the small hours of the morning. Nobody really cares if Mortimer and Whitehouse catch any fish in Gone Fishing – and it’s the same deal here. Cosy viewing with someone near and dead, who is willing to humour your ridiculous supernatural obsessions.

Avoid:

Ghost Adventures: Zak Bagans as an on-screen presence is infuriating, imbued with the kind of obnoxious energy of a six year old doing that ‘trick’ where they only do the opposite of whatever they’re told. Uh-oh, someone said to camera not to fuck about with this cursed doll/religious box/old family heirloom, guess what Zak’s going to have to do now!!!

Jack Osbourne’s Night of Terror: You start out thinking there is nothing scarier than having to spend extended amounts of time with Jack Osbourne. Then he announces his mother will also be joining the latest ghost hunt.

Paranormal Home Inspectors: The concept – a building safety expert listens to the evidence of a ‘haunting’, then systematically shows the reason why someone’s doors keep opening on their own is because they aren’t installed properly – is hilarious. The delivery is utterly tedious, with a botched running order to try and leave a false sense of hope that actually there are still ghosts. For a glimpse of what could have been, check out Jenny Nicholson’s 30-minute breakdown of the series instead.

Journalist and critic living and working in Amsterdam.

Leave a Reply