Posted in

Submit to where your film actually belongs, not where you want to belong

Seven years ago, Josh Trett became the first filmmaker to be reviewed by Indy Film Library, and has returned with two different projects in the years since. In a guest piece for IFL, he explains that the trio of shorts – including Potwash, which recently screened at the Smodcastle Film Festival in New Jersey – have given him an important insight into selecting festivals for his work – and how new independent directors might find the right fit for their own projects in the future.

I flew 3,500 miles to meet Silent Bob. But picture this: standing in the lobby of Smodcastle Cinemas in Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey, I found out it wasn’t to be.

I was surrounded by other wannabe-indie-darlings, adjusting the collars of their Mooby’s shirts, clutching to-be-signed Dogma memorabilia, all eagerly awaiting to see the man himself, Kevin Smith, director of the Clerks trilogy, Chasing Amy and err…Tusk to take the stage in his home town and charm us all with a Q&A. The audience was mostly made up of the filmmakers of his own Smodcastle Film Festival.

We keenly took our seats. Soon, a gentleman named Ernie O’Donnell, an instrumental part of the festival – a childhood friend and co-star of Smith’s in Clerks – took to the stage to inform us Kevin wasn’t in the building at all. He was, in fact, in Canada, shooting a new movie. Cue groans and dropped shoulders – only for Smith’s smiley, bearded face to flash on the cinema’s screen, seconds later. He was in attendance – carrying out the panel virtually, through a Zoom call, smoking weed.

Despite the main man not making his own film festival, spirits remained high. After all, even without this digital cameo, film festivals are about much more than meeting our movie-making heroes.

The festival experience

Smodcastle Cinemas (previously Atlantic Moviehouse) was purchased by Smith and his partners a few years back, to save it from going under following the Pandemic. Nestled in his hometown and only a short walk from the Quick Stop Groceries, where his famous directorial debut was filmed. Soon into his ownership, O’Donnell and Smith started the Smodcastle Film Festival, where filmmakers like myself get to have their work on the big screen. I can’t help but admire that Smith himself was a filmmaker that started with a small indie film and now, decades later, is using that success to keep the independent scene alive, using it as a platform for a new generation of filmmakers. The team he has built to run the festival are all involved in film production in their own right, and couldn’t be more welcoming to jet-laggers like myself.

I’d flown to a borough in New Jersey, a hotel off a busy road surrounded by a Kohl’s, a Jersey Mike’s Subs and an Outback Steakhouse. No strolling to take in the sights here, you can’t walk anywhere in this part of New Jersey, so Uber it was.

Here I was, taking my short film set in a British pub kitchen to the Smodcastle Film Festival.  Film festivals are a great experience if done right. There can be little room for social awkwardness with all the networking and post-movie after parties with other directors, actors and festival teams. Despite flying that far, I ended up spending a lot of time with a fellow English filmmaker Zoe Whittaker, who is currently experiencing her own successful film festival run with her short film ‘Uncle Artoo’. We chatted about our careers so far, our separate festival experiences and the irony of travelling this far only to spend time with another Brit.

I was there with my short film Potwash, for what is likely its penultimate screening. Despite being a film grounded in various British ways (many Americans don’t even know what ‘potwash’ means), it has found a much stronger audience in the US, compared to its ‘home’ circuit. We didn’t even get into the Norwich Film Festival, where I’m from, and where we made the bloody thing!

At Smodcastle, we also were lucky to open for a new feature film. Skweezy Jibbs Makes a Movie, from TikTok comedian Skweezy Jibbs (real name Tim Savage.) Skweezy has an audience already baked for his online skits (one such involves him flying to India by mistake instead of Indiana), so we got to piggyback off his fanbase and turnout. I think this is an important note that you can’t always plan but it shows that film festival programming and scheduling can make a huge difference to how a short film is received and who actually sees it.

Pictures courtesy of Josh Trett.

Know your audience

This has been an important lesson for me. Each film has its own journey. As an independent filmmaker, you cannot assume what works for one project, will work for all projects.

My last short film Dial found success at festivals locally and internationally, while Potwash has had an unexpectedly stronger response overseas, particularly in North America. While Potwash missed out on selection at the last Norwich Film Festival, Dial was nominated. It also won best horror at Cannes Indie Short awards, an amazing festival I attended in 2025, set in the heart of Cannes where they get the audience pumped up by clapping and booming an appropriate music track before the screening starts. Not to mention an opening gala at a two-Michilen-starred-restaurant. But again, Potwash didn’t make the cut.

Another lesson I learned the hard way, was that success at one event doesn’t guarantee the exact same experience with the next one, even when you get selected. The film takes a fairly bold turn in its climax; and the audience in New Jersey were nearly jumping out of their seats and laughing until the credits rolled. I even heard somebody exclaim ‘that was great!’. This is the type of response filmmakers dream of. I could have cried. But when the film played at Suffolk Shorts earlier this year, we received total silence. The same film, but a completely different reaction. I’m torn if this is because American audiences are maybe more expressive (I’m certainly not complaining if that is the case) or, because the Smodcastle Film Festival attracts a particular kind of audience who will appreciate a film like Potwash’s darker humour.

My point on this, especially if you’re looking to take your film to festivals for the first time, is it is really hard to know where your film belongs and where or who your audiences are. I submitted Potwash to as many film festivals as I could afford. As I mentioned, I even applied to some I’d found success with my last short, only to be faced with dozens of rejections. There is such an unpredictability to the rejections too. I really thought I had a shoo-in because of a previous selection, or was convinced my film belonged there. But it doesn’t work like that.

The key takeaway is that filmmakers need to research the festivals we’re submitting to but specifically, the types of films they’re actually selecting. It takes time, but it is worth it – not least because every submission costs money.

Look at the past programmes. Can you imagine your movie sitting comfortably in that line up? It can’t be too similar, of course, but it can’t be too different either. After a few rejections, I’d look up what actually was selected, and realise “Oh. I was never right for this.” When I looked at the film festivals we were actually selected for, suddenly, the programming made much more sense. “We do belong in this one. I see it now.”

After taking around three films on the film festival circuit, I feel I have a stronger idea of what to do. Submit to where your film actually belongs, not where you want to belong. Even when it comes to festivals you might get into, it is also worth considering where will enable you to help build your profile best. After all, it costs money to attend, and we are indie filmmakers; we probably aren’t going to see a financial return for any of this.

Outside of your own projects, I’d also advise you to attend as many film festivals as you can and watch as many films as you can. It’s valuable networking, and I think if you want people to watch your film, it’s only fair you hang around to watch theirs. I’ve been to a few where filmmakers turn up to watch their own film, then run off. Charming. Ideally, though, you’re also going to be connecting with these people, so if you can talk about each other’s films, then great.

In the case of Smodcastle, this all came together. Seeing your film connect with strangers, not just mum and dad, and if you’re lucky, your neighbours budgie, is rewarding and educational. Plus, I imagine that is why so many of us chose to make these films in the first place. This time, I’d flown thousands of miles for the validation of a director I admire – and actually found it from an audience of complete strangers. A reminder of why I made this film and damn, do I need that reminder now more than ever.

Leave a Reply